Toggle Menu
Host a fun mystery party.
Search
Sign in
or
Register
(
)
close
Sign in
or
Register
Murder Mystery Parties
Shop All Murder Mystery Parties
Adult Mystery Parties
Teen Mystery Parties
Kid's Mystery Parties
Catch a Killer Games
Virtual Mystery Parties
Non Murder Games
Party Packs
Shop All Party Packs
Adult Mystery Party Boxed Sets
Teen Mystery Party Boxed Sets
Kid's Mystery Party Boxed Sets
Upgrade your Download
Props
Game Extras
Shop All Game Extras
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Game Rating System
Add murder mystery players
Gift Certificates
Commercial Licenses
The Author
Testimonials
Help Choosing a Mystery
Shop All Help Choosing a Mystery
All Female Groups
All Male Groups
Co-ed Games
Retro Murder Mystery Parties
Virtual Murder Mysteries
Mystery Parties by Season
Halloween Mystery Parties
Christmas | Holiday Games
Gift Certificates
Home
Help Choosing a Mystery
Help Choosing a Mystery
Here is the My Mystery Party Game Matching Matrix. Click on the options below to narrow down your selection of games.
Click here for a chart that breaks down the minimum amount of required players with gender for all adult parties.
Subcategories:
All Female Groups
All Male Groups
Co-ed Games
Retro Murder Mystery Parties
Virtual Murder Mysteries
Mystery Parties by Season
Halloween Mystery Parties
Christmas | Holiday Games
Sort By:
Featured Items
Newest Items
Best Selling
A to Z
Z to A
By Review
Price: Ascending
Price: Descending
1
2
Next
Quick View
Once Upon a Murder | Mystery Party
$42.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Mullets, Mayhem, & Murder
$48.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Murder on Baker Street
$48.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
The Murder of Archibald Grim
$46.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
The Noxhelm Murders | A murder mystery game
$46.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Last Will & Testament of Roland Kingsley
$50.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Mystery at the Oster Awards
$48.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Sin City Slayer casino murder mystery
$48.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Bloodwood Masquerade Murder Mystery
$48.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
1920s Murder Mystery Party
$45.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Last Will of Hunter Bentley
$52.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
1986 | a Sinister '80s Murder Mystery
$48.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
'80s Murder Mystery Game
$48.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Teen Idol Awards murder mystery
$46.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Murder at the Toadwart Inn murder mystery
$40.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Escape from Dregs Island
$46.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Saints & Sinners Party | A murder mystery game
$46.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Murder in the Escape Room
$42.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Hatter's Ball | A Murder Mystery Game
$48.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Factions | A Murder Mystery
$42.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Wild West Murder Mystery
$40.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Murder at Anonville Manor mystery party
$46.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Murder at Devonshire Manor mystery party
$42.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
High School Reunion | 80's Prom Mystery Game
$45.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Murder Behind the Mirror
$46.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
The Greatest Murder on Earth | a murder mystery game
$42.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Murder at the Poe's Raven Party
$48.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Daunting Diamond Thievery mystery party
$40.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Murder on the Buffalo Express | Mystery Party
$48.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Wine Tasting Murder Mystery Game
$40.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Roman Toga Murder Mystery Party Game
$46.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
1920s Murder Mystery Party on the Boardwalk
$42.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
CSI murder mystery party game
$45.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Abby Manor Masquerade Ball Murder Mystery
$48.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
614 Scarlet Ct. Murder Mystery Block Party
$50.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Cadbury Mansion murder mystery game
$46.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Superhero Assassination Murder Mystery
$40.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Prognosis: Murder | '90s Murder Mystery Game
$42.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Murder at the Album Release Party Game
$42.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Hero and Villain Summit murder mystery party
$42.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Scary Movie Night | a non-murder mystery party
$42.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Witch murder mystery party
$40.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Pirate Murder Mystery game
$40.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
The Game Master's Virtual Escape | virtual mystery party
$49.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Murder at the Magnolia Avenue Block Party
$44.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
'60s Murder Mystery Party
$42.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Panic at the House of Groove | 70's Mystery Party
$44.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
1950s Greaser Murder Mystery Party
$46.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Murder at the Plaza Ritz
$91.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Back in Time for Murder Time Travel mystery party
$46.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Doom Mansion murder mystery game
$40.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Murder at the Stratford Castle murder mystery
$112.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Harrison House murder mystery game
$112.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Game of Crowns
$42.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Zombie Escape | A mystery game
$46.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Poolside Murder Mystery Party
$46.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Murder at the Luau murder mystery party game
$45.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Murder in Maui - a Hawaiian Luau Murder Mystery
$40.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Grillin', Chillin', and Killin' murder mystery party
$44.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Corporate Chaos Murder Mystery Party
$50.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Find the Spy Before you Die mystery party
$42.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Turmoil at the Talent Show
$46.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Pajama Party Pandemonium
$46.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
The Mystery at Godley Grove Manor game
$44.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Find the Spy: Ms. Crimson
$42.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Vampire murder mystery party
$42.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Once Upon a Mystery | Virtual Non-Murder Game
$46.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Bridal Shower Murder Mystery
$42.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Cinco de Mayo Fiesta murder mystery game
$45.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
The Thanksgiving Saboteur | Virtual Mystery Party
$49.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Who Kidnapped Santa | Virtual mystery
$46.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Murder in 1985 | A Virtual Murder Mystery
$46.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
When the Clock Strikes Murder| Virtual Mystery
$46.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
The Charmstone Academy Murder | Virtual Game
$46.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Surviving Quarantine | Virtual Challenge Game
$49.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Murder at Studio 78 | Virtual murder mystery
$49.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Murder at the Red Rose Masquerade | Virtual Murder Mystery
$49.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
The Manhattan Murders | Virtual murder mystery
$49.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
A Night of Creeps, Haunts, & Murder | Virtual Mystery
$50.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Who Whacked the Mole? | A virtual '20s murder mystery
$46.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Murder in Dreary Hollow | Virtual Murder Mystery
$46.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
The Murder of Miles Randolph | Virtual Murder Mystery
$46.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
The Assassin Among the Crew | Virtual Murder Mystery
$49.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Holly O. Wene's Halloween Party mystery game
$40.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Murder at the Mardi Gras Masquerade Ball game
$40.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Bumped Off on Bourbon Street murder mystery party
$44.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
As the Beads Drop: Mardi Gras Murder Mystery
$42.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Foul Play in the French Quarter | Virtual Murder Mystery
$49.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
St. Patrick's Shamrocks and Murder Mystery
$45.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
St. Patrick's Murder Me, I'm Irish Mystery
$48.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Cinco de Mayo Mayhem murder mystery game
$44.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
The Deadly Derby Murder Mystery Party
$45.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Family St. Patrick's Day Mystery Party
$42.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Easter Mystery Party Game
$46.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Pumpkin Palooza Costume Ball Mystery
$42.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Zombie Murder Mystery Game
$46.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Family Halloween Whodunit
$42.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Monster murder mystery party
$50.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Murder at the Walgrave Astoria Costume Ball
$50.95
Compare
Compare
Items
Quick View
Murder at Skull Manor Costume Ball murder mystery
$42.95
Compare
Compare
Items
1
2
Next
Close
×
OK
