• Home
• Help Choosing a Mystery Party

Help Choosing a Mystery Party

Here is the My Mystery Party Game Matching Matrix. Click on the options below to narrow down your selection of games. Click here for a chart that breaks down the minimum amount of required players with gender for all adult parties. 

• 
  A Night of Creeps, Haunts, & Murder | Virtual Mystery $50.95

  Compare
• 
  Murder on Baker Street $48.95

  Compare
• 
  Murder at the Poe's Raven Party $48.95

  Compare
• 
  The Murder of Archibald Grim $46.95

  Compare
• 
  The Noxhelm Murders | A murder mystery game $46.95

  Compare
• 
  Last Will & Testament of Roland Kingsley $50.95

  Compare
• 
  Mystery at the Oster Awards $48.95

  Compare
• 
  Sin City Slayer casino murder mystery $48.95

  Compare
• 
  Bloodwood Masquerade Murder Mystery $48.95

  Compare
• 
  1986 | a Sinister '80s Murder Mystery $48.95

  Compare
• 
  Murder Behind the Mirror $46.95

  Compare
• 
  Wonderful Wilderness Scavenger Hunt $22.95

  Compare
• 
  Once Upon a Murder mystery party game $42.95

  Compare
• 
  '80s Murder Mystery Game $48.95

  Compare
• 
  Teen Idol Awards murder mystery $46.95

  Compare
• 
  1920s Murder Mystery Party $45.95

  Compare
• 
  Murder at the Toadwart Inn murder mystery $40.95

  Compare
• 
  Costume Ball | Virtual Halloween Non-Murder $46.95

  Compare
• 
  Saints & Sinners Party | A murder mystery game $46.95

  Compare
• 
  Murder in the Escape Room $42.95

  Compare
• 
  Hatter's Ball | A Murder Mystery Game $48.95

  Compare
• 
  Factions | A Murder Mystery $42.95

  Compare
• 
  Pumpkin Palooza Costume Ball Mystery $42.95

  Compare
• 
  Zombie Murder Mystery Game $46.95

  Compare
• 
  Wild West Murder Mystery $40.95

  Compare
• 
  Family Halloween Whodunit $42.95

  Compare
• 
  Witch murder mystery party $40.95

  Compare
• 
  Monster murder mystery party $50.95

  Compare
• 
  Murder at the Walgrave Astoria Costume Ball $50.95

  Compare
• 
  Vampire murder mystery party $42.95

  Compare
• 
  Murder at Skull Manor Costume Ball murder mystery $42.95

  Compare
• 
  Cadbury Mansion murder mystery game $46.95

  Compare
• 
  Sanitarium Murder Mystery Party $40.95

  Compare
• 
  Murder at Anonville Manor mystery party $46.95

  Compare
• 
  Holly O. Wene's Halloween Party mystery game $40.95

  Compare
• 
  Haunted house murder mystery game $46.95

  Compare
• 
  Haunted Hotel Homicide murder mystery $40.95

  Compare
• 
  Halloween Homicide in Dark Cloud murder mystery $42.95

  Compare
• 
  Murder at Devonshire Manor mystery party $42.95

  Compare
• 
  Thanksgiving Murder Mystery Game $42.95

  Compare
• 
  The Greatest Murder on Earth | a murder mystery game $42.95

  Compare
• 
  Thanksgiving Mystery Party | Non-Murder $46.95

  Compare
• 
  Daunting Diamond Thievery mystery party $40.95

  Compare
• 
  Murder in 1985 | A Virtual Murder Mystery $46.95

  Compare
• 
  Wine Tasting Murder Mystery Game $40.95

  Compare
• 
  1920s Murder Mystery Party on the Boardwalk $42.95

  Compare
• 
  CSI murder mystery party game $45.95

  Compare
• 
  Abby Manor Masquerade Ball Murder Mystery $48.95

  Compare
• 
  614 Scarlet Ct. Murder Mystery Block Party $50.95

  Compare
• 
  Murder at Studio 78 | Virtual murder mystery $49.95

  Compare
• 
  The Assassin Among the Crew | Virtual Murder Mystery $49.95

  Compare
• 
  The Manhattan Murders | Virtual murder mystery $49.95

  Compare
• 
  Who Whacked the Mole? | A virtual '20s murder mystery $46.95

  Compare
• 
  Bad Santa | A hilarious murder mystery party $52.95

  Compare
• 
  Who Stole the Silver Bells Christmas mystery party $42.95

  Compare
• 
  Who Slayed Santa murder mystery party $57.95

  Compare
• 
  Christmas toyshop mystery party $50.95

  Compare
• 
  Murder at the Ugly Christmas Sweater Party $50.95

  Compare
• 
  Murder at the Kringels Christmas mystery game $48.95

  Compare
• 
  Christmas Reindeer Mystery Party $46.95

  Compare
• 
  Homicide at the Tacky Sweater Shindig murder mystery $42.95

  Compare
• 
  Crazy Christmas Catastrophe mystery party $42.95

  Compare
• 
  Christmas Murder Mystery: T'was the Night Before Murder $46.95

  Compare
• 
  Superhero Assassination Murder Mystery $40.95

  Compare
• 
  Murder at the Red Rose Masquerade | Virtual Murder Mystery $49.95

  Compare
• 
  Prognosis: Murder | '90s Murder Mystery Game $42.95

  Compare
• 
  Escape from Dregs Island $46.95

  Compare
• 
  Poolside Murder Mystery Party $46.95

  Compare
• 
  Murder at the Luau murder mystery party game $45.95

  Compare
• 
  Murder at the Album Release Party Game $42.95

  Compare
• 
  Murder in Maui - a Hawaiian Luau Murder Mystery $40.95

  Compare
• 
  Grillin', Chillin', and Killin' murder mystery party $44.95

  Compare
• 
  The Thanksgiving Saboteur | Virtual Mystery Party $49.95

  Compare
• 
  Murder in Dreary Hollow | Virtual Murder Mystery $46.95

  Compare
• 
  The Murder of Miles Randolph | Virtual Murder Mystery $46.95

  Compare
• 
  Hero and Villain Summit murder mystery party $42.95

  Compare
• 
  Murder on the Buffalo Express | Mystery Party $48.95

  Compare
• 
  Resort Scavenger Hunt Challenge $24.95

  Compare
• 
  Cruise Ship Scavenger Hunt $27.95

  Compare
• 
  Amusement Park Scavenger Hunt $24.95

  Compare
• 
  Big Present Scavenger Hunt $19.95

  Compare
• 
  Pirate Murder Mystery game $40.95

  Compare
• 
  Surviving Quarantine | Virtual Challenge Game $49.95

  Compare
• 
  The Game Master's Virtual Escape | virtual mystery party $49.95

  Compare
• 
  Murder at the Magnolia Avenue Block Party $44.95

  Compare
• 
  '60s Murder Mystery Party $42.95

  Compare
• 
  1970's Disco Murder Mystery Game $44.95

  Compare
• 
  1950s Greaser Murder Mystery Party $46.95

  Compare
• 
  Murder at the Plaza Ritz $91.95

  Compare
• 
  Back in Time for Murder Time Travel mystery party $46.95

  Compare
• 
  Doom Mansion murder mystery game $40.95

  Compare
• 
  Murder at the Stratford Castle murder mystery $112.95

  Compare
• 
  Harrison House murder mystery game $112.95

  Compare
• 
  Game of Crowns $42.95

  Compare
• 
  Roman Toga Murder Mystery Party Game $46.95

  Compare
• 
  Foul Play in the French Quarter | Virtual Murder Mystery $49.95

  Compare
• 
  Corporate Chaos Murder Mystery Party $50.95

  Compare
• 
  Egg-stra Special Easter Scavenger Hunt $21.95

  Compare
• 
  Find the Spy Before you Die mystery party $42.95

  Compare
• 
  Scary Movie Night | a non-murder mystery party $42.95

  Compare