Who Stole the Silver Bells? Christmas mystery party

Usually ships from our store in 2-3 business days
Write a Review
Gift wrapping:
Options available
Current Stock:

Non-murder Christmas mystery party for 8-24+ players depending upon which kit size you choose above. Ages 13+ for difficulty. There are 8 required characters in the game.  Great for families, church groups, schools or anybody who wants to enjoy a fun night of mystery during the holiday season!

Select the party ready option above, and our staff will fold and slip the clue cards for rounds one, two, and three into the envelopes to prevent you from seeing spoilers on the round cards.  If you do not select this option, you will have some assembly required with your kit. The download version is a different product and does not come with the party pack, as they are not seamless and materials should not be used together. 

Four out of ten for difficulty.

Helpful Links:



Host character list for main game players #1-12
Host character list for players #13-24 (expansion pack #1)


Invitation for Kit A (12 players)
Invitation for Kit B-C (24 unique players and Kit C has expandable teams)
Sample game materials.
Download version of the game
Pre-game player site for Kit A
Pre-game player site for Kit's B-C


 Mystery synopsis:

Citizens of Holly Hills: save the date, mark your calendars, and set your alarms – the annual Snowflake Manor Tacky Sweater party held in honor of the Holly Hills Christmas Queen is just around the corner! As you all know, Martha May Bells has been crowned the Christmas Queen again this year - for the 8th year in a row! The townspeople should all take note of her bountiful Christmas spirit and strive to be like her during the holiday season. Her home on Jolly Street in the Sugarplum Point subdivision is decorated with ornamentation and lights from all over the world! It is a fantastic sight to see! This charming event will take place in the spectacular Silver Bells Ballroom of the Snowflake Manor. The famous Holly Hills silver bells will be on display in the foyer of the manor for all to admire! Party guests will mingle in tacky sweater garb with enchanting people, exquisite food, and fabulous entertainment. A night to remember, you will make lovely Christmas memories for years to come! Dress to impress in your Christmas tacky sweater best! This is where your story begins. 

Kit sizes:  

A: 8-12 players from the main game kit 

B: 8-24 players from the main game kit and expansion pack #1

C: 8-24 players from the main game kit and expansion pack #1 and 10 duplicate team members from the Griswall Family.  

Follow My Mystery Party's board Ugly Christmas Sweater Party on Pinterest.
Minimum age:
13 years
Number of players:
8 - 12 players
Available expansion pack:
12 players
Expandable teams:
Yes, expands to ~ 40 guests
Gender of players:
Co-ed, can be played as an 8 female game with the 12 player kit or 15 female player game with the 24 player kit - see character lists for details)