Witch murder mystery party

Instant Download (PDF)
Write a Review
Current Stock:

This witch-themed murder mystery party is an entertaining and slightly spooky time for 5-8 witches. Gather your wands, practice your cackle, and get ready to sleuth an awesome & spooky witch murder mystery! It doesn't have to be Halloween to dress as witches, you know, so have this witchy party at any time of the year! This is the instant download upon purchase version of the game - no waiting, nothing to ship so you avoid shipping fees! Easy to host, easy to prepare. 

There are four PDF files to download with this game - a host instruction file, printable file, solution key, and an optional free invitation file. 

4 out of 10 star difficulty.This game was updated on 8/15/22.

Helpful Links:

Host character list
Free, printable invitation
Sample game materials
8 character, Expansion pack #1 (Use first. Purchased separately)
8 character, Expansion pack #2 (Purchased after Expansion pack #1)
Boxed version (Our staff will prepare your kit)
Free, pre-game site at Your Mystery Party

Murder Mystery Synopsis:

The members of the 1300th Witch’s Coven are set to arrive at the enchanted Ravenwood Forest for the yearly gathering. The witches will prepare brews, practice new spells, and gossip about warlocks! However, some witches are concerned that the chemistry of the coven hasn’t been right lately. A few have voiced strong opinions about making some of the witches attend sessions with a counselor to learn how to get along before the gathering. Onyx Blazen isn’t taking heed to any of the nonsense and has made it mandatory for all witches of the coven to attend.

You are a member of the 1300th Coven. This is where your story begins. 

Follow My Mystery Party's board One Too Many Witches Will Spoil The Brew - Murder Mystery Party on Pinterest.

If you wish to host this (or any other) game for profit, you will need a commercial license - click here.

Minimum age:
13 years
Difficulty rating:
Moderate, 4/10
Gender of character roles:
# of players in main game:
5-8 players
Expansion pack(s):
8 players, 8 players
Expandable team players:
Date of publication:
2008. Last revised on 8/15/22
Game license:
Single, private use. See game license Terms and Conditions below.


  • 5
    Fun teen game!

    Posted by Unknown on Aug 23rd 2021

    Group of 7 girls played and had a blast for a sweet 16 party. We would definitely buy another game to try more stories.

  • 5
    Witch's spoil murder mystery

    Posted by Unknown on Nov 1st 2020

    So much fun! It was my first time hosting a murder mystery party and it was really easy to follow along. All of my guests were also first-timers at the murder mystery party and so many of them left saying that we have to plan another one sometime.

  • 5
    Great fun for all!

    Posted by Unknown on Sep 10th 2020

    Just did this murder mystery over the weekend with 4 gal friends and we all had a blast. It's so much fun getting into character and a great way to spend a Saturday evening on vacation. And a great activity for these times as you can do everything socially distanced!

  • 4
    We had a ball!

    Posted by Unknown on Jan 5th 2020

    The evening was well paced, supplemental activities kept it varied and interesting. Will definitely do more of these this year!

  • 5
    Perfect for teens

    Posted by Unknown on Oct 29th 2018

    This party was a blast for 13-15yr olds. Each round had the right amount of new info to keep the party moving. We have tried these kind of parties from other writers but this is format by far our favorite. Will definitely buy again.

  • 5
    Perfect Girls Night!

    Posted by Alanna on Aug 12th 2018

    We did this for a friend's birthday. Imaging six forty-something-year-old witches murdering each other...with a bit of hip hop and 80's So You Think You Can Spooky Dance between rounds. What a blast we all had! The pre-game texts were hilarious and got us all in the mood. Highly recommended! We will definitely plan another murdery mystery night!

  • 4
    Aussie witches on the boil

    Posted by Unknown on Sep 18th 2017

    Really enjoyed this game. Clues flowed well. Had lots of fun. Unexpected ending. Some of the game content was very american to us aussies.

  • 5
    Played last night - WOW!

    Posted by Tracy on Jun 29th 2016

    We had more fun than should be legal. My crazy group of friends went all out with their costumes. The pre game activities were hysterical and they got totally into their characters. Mad fun!