null
/
Sale

The Butler Didn't Do It. Or...Did He? | Charming Mystery Games

(No reviews yet) Write a Review
$89.95
SKU:
BUTLER
Availability:
Usually ships from our store within 2 business days.
Gift wrapping:
Options available
Age Range:
14 to Adults
Setting:
In the grim town of Graveshade, a scandal-plagued mayor and those closest to him become entangled in a deadly web of secrets, lies, and murder.
Difficulty:
Moderate, 5.5/10
Brand:
Charming Mystery Games | Game is Played with Charm Evidence, non-roleplay
Roles:
None for Players. There are 6 Characters in the Storyline (1 Victim, 5 Suspects). Players have a Collective Detective Role.
Main Game Players:
8 Players have Charm Sets, but More Spectators Can Play. Can play with < 8.
Total Players:
24 Would Be Max with 3 Players per Charm Set
Vibe & Content Notes:
Clean Small Town Scandal | Traditional Mansion | Great for Any Group
Game Style:
Murder | Non-Roleplaying with Charms/Cards/Forensic Report | 2 Rounds and the Solution
Date of Publication:
June 15, 2026
Adding to cart… The item has been added

Description

A Murder Mystery Party Game Told Through Charms

In this immersive, non-roleplaying murder mystery game, players don’t just read a story—they piece it together. And each player will receive an epic keychain with a set of charms that hold clues used to solve the case. There are eight keychain charm sets in each set for an 8 player game. You can also play with fewer than 8 players, or even solo if you're sharp and don't need a partner to talk things out!

The keychains are collectible and double as souvenirs. Functional keychains - they can be hooked to anything to remind your players of the amazing time they had with you. They're also great conversation starters! This is a physical game, and there is nothing to be downloaded - you'll receive a gift-worthy kit, delivered to your door. 

Something is wrong at Dravenko Manor.

The mayor’s whirlwind marriage has stirred whispers across the grim town of Graveshade. His new wife arrived with secrets… her estranged celebrity niece brings unwanted attention… and her eccentric son is as unpredictable as they come. Even Bandit, the mayor’s loyal dog, seems uneasy.

Through it all, the butler keeps the estate running smoothly—quietly managing the chaos and keeping nosy neighbors in check. Until today.  A murder has been committed. We need you and your friends to help solve the case!

Game Trailer Video

How to Play - This is a non-roleplaying murder mystery game.

1. Round One, players match the 8 charm sets to the 8 role cards, revealing information about each suspect, the victim, and the crime scene.

2. Round Two, the game opens up:

  • Players receive discussion cards with more clues and will mingle, pose questions, compare theories, uncover motives, secrets, and contradictions. 
  • Players deduce the clues, solve the crime. Every player holds a piece of the story through their charm set.
    • Which suspect had the biggest motive?
    • Which suspect had the opportunity?
    • And which suspects are hiding something… in plain sight?
  • A forensic report is delivered and reviewed that holds the final pieces of the puzzle, and players will submit their best guesses of whodunit.

3. Round Three, players make their accusations before the group opens the answer key and reveals the truth. 

The Goal

Solve the mystery before anyone else. Or better yet—be the only one who gets it exactly right.

What’s Included

  • 8 Charm Keychains (with up to 5 clues each)
  • Velvet drawstring bag labeled 'Charm Set Evidence'
  • 8 Role Cards (6 suspects, 1 victim, 1 crime scene)
  • 8 Mystery Investigation Cards
  • 8 Discussion Cards
  • Forensic Report inside of a labeled envelope
  • Host & Player Instructions on a 6" by 9" Card
  • Solution inside of a labeled envelope

Butler Didn't Do it - a murder mystery party game played with charms.

Game Details

  • Players: Up to 8
  • Ages: 14 to Adults
  • Difficulty: Moderate
  • Game time: 1-2 hours (host sets the pace)
  • Play Style: Structured, social, and story-driven
  • Non-Roleplaying

Why You’ll Love It

  • A murder mystery you solve through physical clues that double as souvenirs
  • Built for conversation, deduction, and dramatic accusations and reveals
  • Perfect for parties, game nights, or any type of gatherings

The truth is hidden in the charms! 
The question is… will you see it in time?

Charming Mystery Games is a division of My Mystery Party, LLC