Murder at the Toadwart Inn murder mystery

Instant Download Upon Purchase (PDF)
Write a Review
Current Stock:

Dust off your robes and wands and get ready for your next Witch & Wizard murder mystery party! This is an in-person, traditional mingling (face-to-face) format. A hilarious witch & wizard themed murder mystery party game for 14+ years, 6-10 characters. 10 Character Expansion pack is available. This is the instant download upon purchase version of the game - no waiting, no shipping fees! Everything you need to play is in the download!  Easy to host, easy to prepare. 

You will receive a host instruction, solution, and printable file with this download. The free invitation is below, under helpful links. 

This game was updated on 8/24/21

Five out of ten difficulty.

Helpful Links:

Click here to view the character list!
Click here for the free, printable invitation!
Click here to view the 10 character expansion pack
Click here to view sample game materials.
Click here to have My Mystery Party staff prepare your game kit!
Direct your guests to the corresponding invitation site at 'Your Mystery Party'

Mystery synopsis:

The Toadwart Inn is a historical place within the magical community where magical folk gather safely away from the snurbs (i.e. non-magical part of society) to have a wonderful and relaxing time.  Magical beings anticipate the yearly Witch’s Brew Social sponsored by the inn, as the who’s who of the supernatural world will certainly be in attendance.

This event will be the ultimate opportunity for magical beings to taste all of the latest flavors of witch’s brew and catch up on juicy gossip.  The guests are set to arrive at the gathering riding the most outlandish and expensive models of brooms.  Cameras will flash as the Merlin’s Daily and Merlin Morning Timesreporters capture the guests donning this season’s most fashionable hats, robes, and wands.

Get ready for magical challenges, delectable dishes, and merriment with your magical friends!

This is where your story begins. 

Hosting this game for profit?

 You need a commercial license.  We will waive the commercial license fee for registered 501C charities for fundraising events. 

 Follow My Mystery Party's board Murder at the Toadwart Inn - Murder Mystery Party for Witches & Wizards on Pinterest.

Minimum age:
14 years
# of players:
6-10 players
Expansion pack:
10 players
Gender of players:


  • 5
    Murder at Toadwarts was a blast!

    Posted by Krista on Nov 24th 2018

    I organized this murder mystery party for my family. We played it the day after Thanksgiving. Everyone loved it, especially because we all love Harry Potter. I would recommend this to any family or group of friends that wants to have a fun evening.

  • 5
    Great Materials

    Posted by Adam on Jul 1st 2016

    While I haven't been able to actually throw my party yet (it's a surprise birthday for my wife), the materials in this pack are awesome. I decided to throw my wife a Harry Potter themed birthday mystery, and so I've changed some small things here and there for my purposes, but everything is well-written and designed. I'd certainly recommend this to anyone who asked, especially at the price they are asking. Many other packs are more expensive, but this one had everything you need. If you are considering a magical murder mystery party, look no further.