Find the Spy before you Die non-murder mystery party
Challenge mystery party game trailer
Promotional graphic for a 'Find the Spy' challenge game, featuring a white review card with a 5-star rating and an anonymous review, a red 'YOU DIE' stamp, and pixelated green text reading 'find the spy.
Find the Spy before you Die non-murder mystery party
Challenge mystery party game trailer
Promotional graphic for a 'Find the Spy' challenge game, featuring a white review card with a 5-star rating and an anonymous review, a red 'YOU DIE' stamp, and pixelated green text reading 'find the spy.
My Mystery Party

Find the Spy: Mr. Peabody Challenge Game

In stock
4.9 10 reviews
Available for download at checkout
$42.95
Product details
  • Type Download
  • SKU FINDSPY
  • Age Range 14 to Adult
  • Minimum # of Players 8 Suspects
  • Max Players (Main Game) 12 Suspects
  • Max # Available (Sold Separately) 18 Suspects
  • Difficulty Rating Moderate, 6/10
  • Roles Flex-Gender
  • Game Duration 2 - 4 Hours Average (Flexible)
  • Setting At Dr. Percy Peabody’s mansion in Dead Hollow, where guests have gathered for an exclusive VIP dining experience.
  • Game Format Find the Spy (Non-Murder) | Challenge to Win Clues | Guided Clue Mingling | 4 Rounds
  • Vibe & Content Notes Mysterious Atmosphere * Trust Nobody Vibes * Fun, Clean Challenges
  • Publication Date 2015. Last Revised: 2018
Description Included Reviews

A thrilling challenge-based spy mystery party game set during an exclusive VIP dinner at Dr. Percy Peabody’s mansion in gloomy Dead Hollow. This unusual non-murder mystery is packed with secret identities, suspicious guests, physical and intellectual challenges, hidden clues, eccentric personalities, fierce competition, dangerous consequences, the promise of an immense fortune, and a saboteur concealed within the group.

Non-Murder Mystery Party Game Synopsis:

Dr. Percy Peabody has invited an exclusive group of guests to his mansion in the gloomy town of Dead Hollow for a mysterious VIP dining experience. This will be no ordinary dinner party.

During the evening, Dr. Peabody will secretly plant a saboteur among the guests and challenge the group with a series of demanding physical, intellectual, and teamwork-based competitions. Successfully completing the challenges will earn valuable clues that may reveal the identity of the spy hiding among the guests. Every participant has a curious background, an unusual personality, and a possible reason for being selected by the eccentric host.

Some guests may cooperate to uncover the truth, while others could become distracted by rivalries, secrets, and their desire to claim the Peabody fortune. Whoever correctly identifies the saboteur will leave the mansion unscathed with a share of Dr. Peabody’s immense wealth. Those who guess incorrectly may not be so fortunate. You have accepted the challenge—and this is where your story begins.

Expand the Spy Mystery Party Game:
  • Main Game: 12 unique suspect characters
    • Players complete physical, intellectual, and teamwork challenges to earn clues identifying the hidden spy.
  • Expansion Pack #1: 6 additional unique suspect characters
    • Sold separately.
    • Includes 6 optional, gender-flexible roles.
    • The expansion characters may be added in any combination with the optional main-game roles.
    • The expansion pack is not a complete standalone mystery.

All 18 available roles are unique suspect characters. This game does not include duplicate expandable team roles.

Host Character List, Game Preview & Free Resources

This game is licensed for personal, private use only. If you plan to use it for any commercial purpose, public event, business, organization, school, fundraiser, church, promotional activity, paid event, or any use that generates revenue or provides a commercial benefit, you must purchase a Commercial License.

Purchase Commercial License
  • 5 stars: 9 (90%)
  • 4 stars: 1 (10%)
  • 3 stars: 0 (0%)
  • 2 stars: 0 (0%)
  • 1 star: 0 (0%)
G
Gina
Fun time!

We are a family of 4 (2 adults/2 teens) and played with another family of 6 (2 adults/2teens2kids). It was a lot of fun. The adults and teens were the required 8 characters and it was wonderful to have gender neutral names and also optional characters we could assign to the smaller kids. I wish we hadn’t done it at dinner though - I’d recommend doing a buffet of appetizers, snacks, etc. I also highly recommend the chopsticks challenge for round 3! We added M&Ms as an added bonus. All the rounds were fun. I will say our spy had no clue, and I think the overall clues to his/her identity are tough. Overall, it was great, and we will play it again with neighbors and just be hosts.

t
ts davis
Definitely go with older players for this --

This is a TRICKY one, and such fun - the team challenges were HILARIOUS and a good break from wracking our brains trying to figure out the spy clues. Take note of the age minimum and revise upwards if you're working with a crew who gets frustrated easily. It's completely fine to NOT figure out the Spy (other than the whole dying thing), and people who were clueless still had a good time, but this is DEFINITELY a good mental exercise for those who are good with locked-room mysteries and stumping clues.

A
Anonymous
Super fun night!

This was our 2nd murder mystery game we ordered...loved it. Really enjoyed the challenges!

L
Liesa Kliman
Great Fun!

So much fun! My guests are still talking about our spy dinner party. Even my quiet friends had fun with this. We had 14 people and it took close to 3 hours to complete. Highly recommend if you are looking for laughter and great memories.

A
Anonymous
So thrilled!

It was so super simple to download after purchasing and getting the kit ready was a breeze. I loved that I didn't have to wait for anything in the mail and didn't waste money on shipping. So convenient for last minuters like me! The game was a ton of fun - my guests are still laughing! Thanks for this!

J
Jacob
Fantastic Fun

This was our first time using My Mystery Party and it was great! Everyone had a great time and it made for an amazing evening of fun. One of the nine in our group guessed the spy. Great fun, highly recommend

H
Heather
MORE fun than we planned on!

Sending a HUGE THANK YOU to the creative writers of this Mystery package! I had fun planning the evening & even more fun watching it unfold as each character came to life! My teenage daughter wants me to plan her Bday the same way because she's jealous that she missed out on the fun!

I am SO EXCITED!

K
Kristin
So much fun.... Great teen party

This was the first party for any of us to ever do. We did it for a church youth group. It was a hit. We will definitely do another one. The package was well put together and so easy to do. My only regret is in the excitement of it all I forgot to take pictures.

S
Samantha Pottman
So unique, A+++

My group had so much fun with this game. LOVE!

A
Anonymous
Great fun

We played with 8 adults and had a great evening. We did have two players who guessed the spy, but missed lots of clues along the way when the final solution was read out.

The challenges were particularly fun, and set this game apart from other similar style events.